Contact Us

Blog

Why Insurance Companies Benefit from SOC 2 Certified Print Partners

Why Insurance Companies Need SOC 2 Certified Print Partners 

If you’re responsible for choosing a print vendor for your insurance brokerage or company, you probably started by comparing prices per piece. That’s natural—procurement is often judged on cost savings. 

But here’s what should actually be keeping you up at night: your print vendor has access to some of your most sensitive customer data. Policy documents, claims information, customer addresses, financial details—all of it passes through their systems. 

A data breach at your print vendor doesn’t just affect them. It affects YOUR customers, YOUR reputation, and YOUR regulatory standing. And unlike a breach in your own systems, you have limited control over security practices at third-party vendors. 

This is why SOC 2 certification should be non-negotiable when choosing a print partner for insurance communications. Let’s talk about why it matters specifically for the insurance industry. 

The Data Your Print Vendor Handles 

Think about what you’re actually sending to your print provider: 

Policy Documents: 

  • Customer names, addresses, dates of birth 
  • Policy numbers and coverage details 
  • Beneficiary information 
  • Premium amounts and payment methods 
  • Claims history 

Renewal Notices: 

  • Updated coverage information 
  • Premium changes 
  • Payment due dates 
  • Account numbers 

Claims Communications: 

  • Accident or incident details 
  • Medical information (for health and disability insurance) 
  • Financial loss information 
  • Investigation details 

This isn’t just mailing list data—it’s the kind of information that, if breached, could enable identity theft, fraud, or other harm to your policyholders. 

Regulatory Requirements for Insurance Companies 

Canadian insurance companies operate under strict regulatory oversight. OSFI (Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions) provides guidelines for federally regulated insurers, while provincial regulators oversee others. 

The OSFI Technology and Cyber Risk Management guideline specifically addresses third-party risk management. Key requirements include: 

  • Conducting due diligence on service providers that handle sensitive data 
  • Ensuring appropriate security controls are in place 
  • Monitoring third-party compliance on an ongoing basis 
  • Having contingency plans for third-party failures 

Additionally, PIPEDA requires organizations to use contractual or other means to provide comparable protection for personal information while it’s being processed by a third party. 

Here’s the challenge: how do you verify that your print vendor actually has adequate security controls? You could send them a questionnaire, but you’re taking their word for it. You could conduct an on-site audit, but do you have the security expertise to properly evaluate their controls? 

This is where SOC 2 certification becomes invaluable. 

What SOC 2 Means for Insurance Print Services 

SOC 2 is an independent audit framework developed by the American Institute of CPAs (AICPA). For print vendors serving the insurance industry, the most relevant trust service criteria are: 

Security: 

  • How is data protected from unauthorized access? 
  • What controls prevent data breaches? 
  • How are systems monitored for intrusions? 

Confidentiality: 

  • How is sensitive customer information kept confidential? 
  • Who has access to customer data? 
  • How is data destroyed after use? 

Privacy: 

  • How is personal information collected, used, and disclosed? 
  • Is the handling of personal information compliant with privacy laws? 

When a print vendor achieves SOC 2 Type 2 certification, an independent auditor has verified over at least six months (typically a year) that these controls aren’t just documented—they’re working effectively in practice. 

The Real-World Risks of Choosing the Wrong Print Partner 

In 2022, a mid-sized U.S. insurance brokerage used a print vendor to handle policy renewals. The vendor stored customer data in an unsecured database that was subsequently breached. The exposed data included: 

  • 24,000 customer names and addresses 
  • Policy numbers and coverage amounts 
  • Social security numbers (which the print vendor shouldn’t have even retained) 
  • Payment information 

The costs to the insurance brokerage: 

  • $380,000 in notification costs (required mailings to affected customers) 
  • $520,000 for credit monitoring services 
  • $180,000 in regulatory fines 
  • $220,000 in legal fees 
  • Immeasurable reputational damage 

The print vendor had been selected primarily because they were 15% cheaper than competitors. That cost savings evaporated in an instant. 

What SOC 2 Certification Actually Covers 

When evaluating a print vendor’s SOC 2 report, here’s what you should see: 

Physical Security Controls: 

  • Restricted access to production facilities 
  • Surveillance systems 
  • Visitor management procedures 
  • Secure document storage 

Access Controls: 

  • Role-based access to customer data 
  • Multi-factor authentication requirements 
  • Regular access reviews 
  • Immediate termination of access for departed employees 

Data Encryption: 

  • Encryption of data in transit (when you send files to the printer) 
  • Encryption of data at rest (when files are stored) 
  • Secure disposal of data after job completion 

Monitoring and Incident Response: 

  • 24/7 security monitoring 
  • Intrusion detection systems 
  • Documented incident response procedures 
  • Regular security assessments 

Vendor Management: 

  • If the printer uses any subcontractors, how are they vetted? 
  • What security requirements are imposed on subcontractors? 

The Difference Between SOC 2 Type 1 and Type 2 

This is crucial to understand: 

SOC 2 Type 1 is a point-in-time assessment. It confirms the vendor had appropriate controls in place on a specific date. It’s like checking that someone locked their door today—but you don’t know if they lock it every day. 

SOC 2 Type 2 is a period-based assessment, typically covering 6-12 months. It confirms the controls are operating effectively over time. This is what you want for an ongoing print vendor relationship. 

If a vendor says they’re “SOC 2 certified” but won’t specify Type 1 or Type 2, be suspicious. Type 1 is significantly less rigorous. 

Questions to Ask Your Print Vendor 

When evaluating print vendors for insurance communications, ask: 

“Do you have a current SOC 2 Type 2 report?” 

  • If yes, ask for the audit date and how often they renew 
  • If no, this should be disqualifying for insurance work 

“Which trust service criteria does your report cover?” 

  • At minimum: Security and Confidentiality 
  • Ideally: Security, Confidentiality, and Privacy 

“Were there any exceptions or qualifications in your most recent audit?” 

  • No audit is perfect, but material weaknesses should be addressed 

“How do you handle data retention and disposal?” 

  • You want a clear policy: data is only retained as long as necessary for production, then securely destroyed 

“What happens if there’s a security incident affecting our data?” 

  • They should have clear incident notification procedures 

“Do you have cyber liability insurance?” 

  • This doesn’t replace good security, but it shows they understand the risks 

“Are your employees background-checked?” 

  • Anyone handling sensitive insurance data should undergo background screening 

The SOC 2 Report: What You’ll Actually Receive 

If you request a vendor’s SOC 2 report, here’s what you’ll get: 

  1. The Auditor’s Opinion 
  • Did the controls meet the criteria? 
  • Were there any qualifications or exceptions? 
  1. Management’s Assertion 
  • The vendor’s description of their systems and controls 
  1. Description of Tests Performed 
  • What the auditor actually checked 
  1. Test Results 
  • What passed, what failed, what needs improvement 

This document is typically 40-100 pages and contains sensitive information about the vendor’s security practices, so you’ll need to sign an NDA to receive it. 

Beyond SOC 2: Other Security Considerations 

While SOC 2 is the gold standard, also consider: 

ISO 27001: An international standard for information security management systems. It’s complementary to SOC 2 and indicates strong security practices. 

PIPEDA Compliance: Ensure the vendor understands and complies with Canadian privacy law. SOC 2 focuses on security controls, but privacy practices are also critical. 

Insurance Industry Experience: Has the vendor worked with other insurance companies? Do they understand the specific regulatory requirements of the insurance industry? 

Business Continuity: What happens if there’s a fire, flood, or other disaster at the print facility? Do they have redundant systems to ensure your critical communications still go out? 

 

The Cost-Benefit Analysis 

Yes, SOC 2 certified print vendors typically cost more than uncertified competitors. But let’s look at the math: 

Scenario 1: Choosing the Low-Cost Provider 

  • Save 20% on print costs: $15,000 annually 
  • Data breach probability: 5% per year (conservative estimate for unsecured vendors) 
  • Average breach cost: $500,000 
  • Expected annual cost of breach: $25,000 (5% × $500,000) 

Net expected cost: You save $15,000 but add $25,000 in expected breach costs = $10,000 more expensive 

Scenario 2: Choosing the SOC 2 Certified Provider 

  • Pay 20% more for print: Costs $15,000 more annually 
  • Data breach probability: <1% per year (based on strong security controls) 
  • Expected annual breach cost: $5,000 

Net expected cost: $20,000 more expensive, but with 80% less risk 

The key question: would you pay $20,000 for insurance that protects you from a $500,000 liability? Most insurance companies would say yes—after all, that’s your own business model. 

Making the Business Case Internally 

If you need to justify the higher cost of a SOC 2 certified vendor to leadership: 

Frame it as risk management, not a price premium: “The SOC 2 certified vendor costs $20,000 more annually, but provides independently verified security controls that reduce our third-party data breach risk by approximately 80%.” 

Quantify the potential breach costs: Include customer notification costs, regulatory fines, legal fees, credit monitoring services, and reputational damage in your calculation. 

Highlight regulatory requirements: Point to OSFI guidelines or provincial regulatory expectations around third-party risk management. 

Compare to other insurance policies: “We pay $X for cyber liability insurance. This is essentially paying for preventative security controls rather than insurance after the fact.” 

 

The Bottom Line 

Choosing a print vendor for insurance communications shouldn’t be primarily a cost decision—it’s a risk management decision. 

When you send customer data to a print provider, you’re extending your security perimeter to include their systems. A breach at their facility is a breach of your data, and you’ll bear the consequences. 

SOC 2 Type 2 certification doesn’t guarantee perfect security (nothing does), but it provides independent verification that appropriate controls are in place and operating effectively. For insurance companies handling sensitive policyholder data, that verification isn’t a nice-to-have—it’s essential due diligence. 

The few thousand dollars you might save with an uncertified vendor isn’t worth the hundreds of thousands (or millions) you could lose in a breach. 

AIIM is SOC 2 Type 2 certified and specializes in secure print communications for Canadian insurance companies. Learn more about our security practices or request our SOC 2 report.